Newspaper Archive of
Feather River Bulletin
Quincy, California
April 16, 2014     Feather River Bulletin
PAGE 5     (5 of 38 available)        PREVIOUS     NEXT      Full Size Image
PAGE 5     (5 of 38 available)        PREVIOUS     NEXT      Full Size Image
April 16, 2014

Newspaper Archive of Feather River Bulletin produced by SmallTownPapers, Inc.
Website © 2019. All content copyrighted. Copyright Information.     Terms Of Use.     Request Content Removal.

Feather River Bulletin Wednesday, April 16, 2014 5A State proposal designed to protect yellow-legged frog Dan McDonald Managing Editor Which came first, the fish or the frog? In the case of a Plumas County lake, the state says the water belongs to the native frogs. The fish will have to go. The state's plan caught the local Fish and Game Commission by surprise earlier this month. And the local board wasn't happy about it. The commission's board members voted unanimously to oppose the California Department of Fish and Wildlife plan designed to protect critical habitat for the mountain yellow-legged frog. According to CDFW environmental scientist Sarah Mussulman, the brook trout in Gold Lake (located in the Bucks Lake Wilderness Area) are scheduled to be removed with gillnets in late spring or early summer. This Gold Lake is not to be confused with the Gold Lake in the Lakes Basin. Mussulman said a small population of the yellow- legged frog was discovered in nearby Rock Lake. She said removing the non-native trout -- which eat the native frogs -- is an attempt to preserve the frog's critical habitat. She added that Gold Lake represents a rare opportunity to restore the frog population in that area. The critical habitat for the yellow-legged frog includes more than a million acres across 16 counties in California, including Plumas. The state is trying to get the frog added to the endangered species list. Brook trout are not native in the western states. They were introduced to the area from the eastern U.S. beginning in the late 1800s. The brook trout -- which thrive in higher-altitude lakes -:- haven't been stocked in G01d Lake s~age 1966, according to~l~rassulman. But the fish are still there. "The fish eat the (yellow- legged frog) tadpoles and the frogs," Mussulman said. "If it's small enough to fit in a fish's mouth, a fish will eat it." Consequently, Mussulman added, the frogs are rarely found around lakes that have large trout populations. Mussulman said her High Mountain Lakes program began conducting inventories of fish and amphibians across the Sierra Nevada in 2000. The program began in response to a petition to have the yellow-legged frog listed as endangered. She said fish-stocking plans have since been adjusted to eliminate conflicts with the frogs. Some lakes got more fish; others get none. decided to remove the brook trout to benefit the frog population at Rock Lake and possibly re-establish the frogs at Gold Lake in the process. Rock Lake has no trout and the two lakes are sometimes linked by a stream dt~ring the rainy season. Mussulman said no other Plumas County lakes have been targeted for trout removal. "It's important to keep in mind that this is one single lake we are proposing (to remove the trout from)," she said. "We have every intention to continue stocking in mountain lakes." Gold Lake survey Mussulman said Gold Lake was first surveyed by the High Mountain Lakes program in 2004. She said CDFW crews found three adult mountain yellow-legged frogs. In 2010, additional data were gathered. The CDFW The California Department of Fish and Wildlife hopes to preserve yellow-legged frog critical habitat by removing the brook trout from Gold Lake in the Bucks Lake Wilderness Area. Local opposition District fisheries biologist Amber Rossi outlined the state's Gold Lake proposal during the local Fish and Game Commission meeting April 3. Commission board member Ron Horton said he and the other board members were shocked to hear the news. Horton said the local commission should have been consulted during the process. "The (CDFW) will tell you they don't have to consult with us. Maybe legally they don't," Horton said. "But how do they feel it's right to make a decision about our area without at least talking to us? That is arrogance. This is the exact reason we have suspicion of the state and federal governments.., because of that kind of attitude." Horton said he wasn't speaking on behalf of the other commissioners. But he said he was worried that other county lakes would be targeted for non-native trout removal if a yellow-legged frog were spotted nearby. Although brook trout have been in Plumas County for more than 100 years, the only American-Style )'oar Own!" Dinner House SINCE 1937 Fri-Sat-Sun 4-8pm 530-836-2359 6 miles west of Graeagle on Hwy 70 www.mttombainn.eom 60300 Mt.Tomba Rd., Cromberg types of trout considered native to the area are rainbow and cutthroat. Horton added that even some species of rainbow have been re-introduced and aren't technically considered native. them as'many as four times. He said, theoretically, those None have been found. trout could be removed, too.Mussulman added that "If they are considering the some frog populations have brook trout to be non-native, been found near streams. But then all brook trout in all she said removing trout isn't streams and all lakes of Plumas an option in those cases. County are vulnerable to Horton said regardless of removal," Horton said. "If the state's decision to remove that's the criteria, where would brook trout from Gold Lake, it stop? I don't believe it is Plumas County should have going to end with Gold Lake." had some say about it. Mussulman said that, while "To have a four-year study it is possible a new population and we hear about it a month of yellow-legged frog could be before it is about to happen ... discovered locally, it's not That's just not right," he said. very likely. Plumas County Supervisor She said, "There are almost Lori Simpson said she was no (yellow-legged) frogs left" concerned about the state's plan. in the county. She noted "I think it is a drastic every lake in the frog's measure and would like to know habitat area (above 5,000 feet) what other alternatives CDFW has been thoroughly screened looked at," Simpson said. "I for signs of the frog-- some of will be investigating it further." IN ADDITION TO OUR RI:GULAR BI I:AKI:AST & LUNCH MENUS: Bagels & Iox with cream cheese, egg, onion, tomato, & caper Filet mignon & eggs ,our way with hash browns or potatoes O'Brien Vegetarian frittata with hash browns or potatoes O'Brien Trout amandine with snow peas, t-leirloom fingerling potatoes, beurre noisette $6 Bloody Marys, Bellinis, or Mimosas WE WILL HOST A I:Rlgl: I:ASTI:R I:GG HUNT AT NOON FOR KIDS! (FOR THOSg DINING IN TI#g I STAUI ANT) Richard IC Stockton, Please stop by and say, "Hi!" CLU ChFC, Agent Insurance Lic. #0B68653 I'm looking forward to serving Providing Insurance & Financial Services your needs for insurance and 65 W. Main St., Quincy, CA 95971 financial services. (530) 283-0565 Fax (530) 283-5143 Like a good neighbor, State Farm ~s" there. CALL ME TODAY. #t StateFarm st Ld rfn Mountain Hardware and Sports specializes in products for the Mountain Lifestyle and recreational equipment for exploring beautiful Plumas County. Fi:;hing Live Worms Tackle. Bait Flies. Ma :)s River Tubes & Boats.Water Toys Welter Shoes. Bike Rentals Clothing .Home Decor & Gifts Lawn & Garden Paint & Hardware Outdoor Furniture Banc uet Table & Chair Rentals We can assist with all your building needs - from plans to the finished product (530) 283-2035 P.O. Box 1369 QUINCY, CA 95971 LIC. #453927 ...,~ zo~qbo~&: Delicious Breakfast Plates 282 Bonta Street Open 7 Blairsden, Ca a Week